A future maintainable earnings valuation for a sub-$2 million Australian business starts from what the business can sustain, not from what the tax return declares.
Update September 2026
The two numbers diverge because a tax return is built to minimise assessable income within the law, while a valuation is built to estimate the cash a buyer can reasonably expect. The gap is not small, and it is not rare: 92% of Australian businesses have turnover under $2 million, and the $200,000 to under $2 million band alone holds 931,592 businesses, or 35.0% of the total (the ABS business counts published by the Small Business Ombudsman, June 2024 data). This is the mainstream market, not a niche.
Most of those owners do not prepare their own returns. The ATO's own figure on tax agent use puts 88% of small businesses lodging income tax returns through a tax practitioner (ATO, How the ATO is addressing risks in the small business market, 27 May 2021). That matters because the accountant's job is compliance, and the valuer's job is something else entirely.
This guide works through what replaces the tax return, how a future maintainable earnings valuation for a sub-$2 million Australian business is actually built under APES 225, which normalisations decide the number, and how enterprise value becomes the cheque the owner receives.
Key Takeaways:
|
This article is general information only. It is not financial, legal or taxation advice. Valuation, tax and deal outcomes depend on your circumstances, so seek independent advice before acting.
The sub-$2M mirage
The belief that the tax return is the number that counts survives because, for most of a business's life, it is the only number anyone asks for. That changes the moment a buyer's diligence team arrives, and the change is abrupt. The tax return is a record of a past tax position; a buyer is pricing a future stream of cash.
The scale of the compliance system around that record explains why the tax figure is so carefully managed. Small business collectable tax debt reached $35.9 billion in 2024–25, up $19.4 billion, or 118%, from $16.5 billion in 2018–19, and it accounts for 66.1% of the $54.2 billion in total collectable debt (the Auditor-General's report on small business tax debt). The ATO's small business income tax gap estimate puts the shortfall between tax actually collected and tax theoretically payable at $27.2 billion, or 17.4% of theoretical liability, for 2022–23 (ATO, Small business income tax gap, last updated 8 May 2026).
| Key Takeaway: A tax return is a compliance document, not a valuation document. It reports a past tax position under one set of rules; a buyer is pricing a future stream of cash under a different set of assumptions. |
Why tax returns mislead business valuation in Australia: owners rely on them, but they mislead
A tax return answers a different question from the one a buyer is asking. It reports assessable income after deductions, concessions and timing choices that are entirely legitimate and usually beneficial, and it does so for a single financial year. A valuation asks what the business will earn under competent management in normal trading conditions, which is a forward-looking question that no single return can answer.
The ATO's own tax gap program findings show how much of the divergence is ordinary rather than exotic. The overall tax gap was $58.2 billion, or 9.1% of $640 billion in theoretical tax, for 2022–23, with small business the largest contributor in dollar value (ATO, Tax gap program summary findings, last updated 3 Nov 2025). Read alongside the small business income tax gap, the small business share alone is roughly 47% of the total gap.
The COVID period shows the same mechanism in its most extreme form. ABS national accounts data on COVID business support recorded $50.6 billion of government business up to the June 2020 quarter alone, comprising $31.0 billion of Job Keeper, $16.0 billion of Boosting Cash Flow for Employers and $3.6 billion of other COVID subsidies including state grants (ABS, Government support for business, 2 September 2020). Those amounts were real cash, and they landed in the profit figures of the years they were received. They are also, by definition, not maintainable.
What FME really is
Future maintainable earnings is the valuer's estimate of the normalised level of earnings a business can reasonably be expected to sustain into the future under competent management and normal trading conditions. It is not necessarily last year's result, not a simple historical average, and not the accounting profit shown in the financial statements. In practice a valuer starts with the last three years, sometimes three to five, selects an earnings measure that matches the multiple or capitalisation rate being applied, normalises the result, and then weighs trading since year-end, budgets, contracts, industry conditions, customer concentration and known risks before settling on a figure.
The earnings measure you choose changes the multiple, and this is where most owners lose money. PEBITDA is the proprietor's earnings before owner remuneration, used for owner-operated businesses with sub-$1 million EBITDA and valued on EV/PEBITDA multiples. EBITDA is used for professionally managed entities with $1 million or more in EBITDA, usually retains owner salary within the measure, and is valued on EV/EBITDA. SDE measures the total discretionary benefit available to one owner and is the US convention (the firm's worked example on the EBITDA-to-PEBITDA bridge, 2026). The practical consequence: the multiple changes because the buyer profile changes, and you cannot simply add back the owner's wage and then apply a larger EBITDA multiple.
How buyers react in diligence
Buyers do not reject add-backs because they dislike them. They reject them because they cannot substantiate them, and an unsubstantiated adjustment is a risk the buyer prices. The exit readiness checklist names the failures that produce deal friction and valuation discounts: financial statements not up to date; revenue not separated by product or service; personal expenses not identified; EBITDA adjustments that cannot be substantiated; inconsistent cash flow; BAS and tax lodgments not current; working capital requirements not understood; and key customer concentration risks not identified (the exit readiness checklist, 2026).
The ATO's Top 500 findings show how basic the underlying errors usually are, even at the largest private groups (the ATO's Top 500 findings). That is a large-group case rather than a small-business one, but the pattern is instructive: the problem is rarely a sophisticated structure. It is a number nobody documented.
Building FME under APES 225
An APES 225 business valuation starts by fixing the engagement type, because the standard sets the scope before any number is calculated. APES 225 Valuation Services distinguishes a Valuation Engagement, where the member is free to employ the valuation approaches, methods and procedures a reasonable and informed third party would perform; a Limited Scope Valuation Engagement, where the scope is limited or restricted with a material effect on the estimate; and a Calculation Engagement. A Valuation Engagement becomes a limited-scope engagement if a material limitation becomes known during the work (APES 225 Valuation Services, paragraph 2, compiled October 2024).
For a business under $2 million, that distinction is commercial, not academic. It determines what the report can be used for, what it costs, and how much weight a buyer or the ATO will place on it.
At Expert Business Advisors, valuation work is prepared under APES 225 by senior specialists who apply the standard's engagement, evidence and reporting requirements in full. Reports are issued on a fixed-fee basis with the scope defined in writing, and the firm works as an independent adviser rather than as an advocate for a predetermined outcome, so when a buyer's adviser reads the report, the methodology stands on its own evidence rather than on the relationship behind it.
Pro Tip: Ask the valuer, in writing, which engagement type is being performed and why. If the answer is a limited scope or calculation engagement, the report will carry that limitation into every conversation you have with a buyer.
Scope and independence
Scope is agreed in writing before the work starts. APES GN 20 on scope and extent of work for valuation services covers communicating engagement terms and disclosing scope limitations, restrictions and assumptions (APES GN 20 Scope and Extent of Work for Valuation Services, current version). Where the scope is restricted, the limitation travels with the report, and a buyer's adviser will read it that way.
Independence carries similar weight. The ATO's stated common validation triggers include a valuation prepared internally without appropriate expertise, a methodology that appears aggressive or unsupported, large discounts or adjustments, unrealistic forecasts, and valuations that differ materially from recent transactions or market evidence (our ATO market value checklist, 2026). The same source notes that suitably qualified, independent professionals following recognised standards carry greater credibility (when accountants need an independent business valuer). An internally prepared APES 225 business valuation is not automatically wrong, but it starts the conversation on the back foot.
EBIT vs EBITDA
EBIT and EBITDA differ by depreciation and amortisation, and the measure has to match the multiple being applied. Where the buyer is acquiring assets and will fund capital expenditure separately, EBITDA is the conventional measure. Where the business is capital intensive and the buyer is effectively acquiring a depreciating asset base, EBIT can be the more honest starting point, because it charges the business for the assets it consumes.
The measure also has to match the buyer, and this is where the arithmetic stops being abstract. Take a firm's worked example: revenue of $2,500,000, reported EBITDA of $300,000, owner salary of $180,000 and personal vehicle expenses of $20,000. Step one leaves EBITDA at $300,000. Step two adds back the owner salary and the discretionary vehicle expenses to arrive at PEBITDA of $500,000 (the firm's worked example on the EBITDA-to-PEBITDA bridge, 2026).
The trap is what happens next. An owner-operated business working full time is typically valued on 2.5x to 3.5x PEBITDA, giving an indicative enterprise value of $1.25 million to $1.75 million. A business with the same $300,000 EBITDA but a professional manager already employed is typically valued on 4.0x to 5.0x EBITDA, giving $1.2 million to $1.5 million. The multiple changes because the buyer profile changes, not because the add-back was made. Adding back the owner's wage and the applying the larger EBITDA multiple is the single most common error in sub-$2 million pricing, and Australian industry multiple benchmarks put the PEBITDA-to-EBITDA differential at roughly 0.5x to 0.7x across an SME range of about 0.8x to 8.0x (Australian industry multiple benchmarks, 2026).
Evidence standards
APES 225 paragraph 4.6 requires the member to gather sufficient and appropriate evidence by inspection, inquiry, computation and analysis to provide reasonable grounds that the valuation report and conclusions are properly supported, exercising professional judgement on the extent and quality of evidence given the nature of the valuation, the type of service and the use of the report (APES 225 Valuation Services, paragraph 4.6, September 2023 compilation). "Sufficient and appropriate" is the operative phrase, and it is where most owner-prepared add-back schedules fail.
Where information comes from the client, management or a third party, paragraphs 4.8 and 4.9 require the member to consider obtaining a written representation that the historical financial information is complete, accurate and reliable, that the assumptions are reasonable and that no material facts have been omitted. Relying on such a representation makes an assumption that the matter is true unless it is independently evidenced (APES 225 Valuation Services, paragraphs 4.8 and 4.9, September 2023 compilation). A written representation is not a substitute for evidence, and a buyer's adviser will treat it that way.
In practice, the evidence pack the ATO expects to see includes financial statements, tax returns, market evidence, comparable transactions, industry analysis, forecast assumptions and working papers, alongside disclosed key assumptions, identified risks and explained adjustments (what documents you need for a business valuation in Australia). If the add-backs exist only in the owner's head, they are not evidence yet.
Normalisations that decide value
Normalised earnings in an SME valuation are the adjustments that turn a tax-driven profit figure into the earnings a buyer believes will continue. Each one has to be defensible on its own terms, and each one moves the enterprise value by whatever multiple the buyer applies to it. The firm's method is to start with the last three years, sometimes three to five, choose an earnings measure that matches the multiple or capitalisation rate, normalise, and only then weigh trading since year-end, budgets, contracts, industry conditions, customer concentration and known risks before settling on a weighted average where trends or seasonality warrant it (the firm's worked example on the EBITDA-to-PEBITDA bridge, 2026).
| Adjustment | What it is | Evidence a buyer expects | Typical treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owner pay reset | Replacing the owner's actual remuneration with a market salary for the role actually performed | Payroll records, employment contract, a market salary benchmark | Add back actual pay, deduct the market rate plus on-costs |
| One-off and non-recurring items | Costs or income that will not repeat, including COVID-era subsidies | Prior-year comparatives, grant correspondence, invoices, general ledger | Removed from the base year; buyer asks what replaced the income |
| Discretionary and personal expenses | Costs the business bears that a buyer would not, such as personal vehicle expenses | Expense records, logbooks, an item-by-item schedule | Added back where the item is genuinely personal |
| Related-party terms | Rent, management fees or loans between the owner's entities | Lease and loan agreements, comparable market rates | Restated to arm's length terms |
| Non-operating income | Interest, rent or gains unrelated to the trading business | Financial statements and supporting schedules | Removed from maintainable earnings |
Owner pay reset
The owner pay reset is the adjustment that gets argued hardest, because it cuts both ways. An owner paying themselves below market has the actual amount added back and a market salary deducted, which can reduce earnings. An owner paying themselves above market gets the reverse. The firm's worked example shows the mechanism at owner-operator scale, adding back owner salary and personal vehicle expenses to reported EBITDA to arrive at PEBITDA (the firm's worked example on the EBITDA-to-PEBITDA bridge, 2026).
The reset has to carry the statutory cost of employing a replacement. The superannuation guarantee rate reached 12.00% on 1 July 2025, and Payday Super applies from 1 July 2026, with the guarantee calculated on "qualifying earnings" per payday (the 12% superannuation guarantee rate, last updated 17 April 2026). A replacement manager's true cost includes that 12%, and in most cases a buyer will apply it.
One-offs and COVID effects
One-off adjustments are the easiest to explain and the hardest to prove, because the burden sits with the owner to show the item will not recur. The COVID subsidies are the clearest case in recent memory. ABS national accounts data on COVID business support recorded $50.6 billion of government business support in the June 2020 quarter alone, made up of $31.0 billion of Job Keeper, $16.0 billion of Boosting Cash Flow for Employers and $3.6 billion of other COVID subsidies including state grants (ABS national accounts data on COVID business support, 2 September 2020). The independent evaluation of Job Keeper put the program's total cost at $88.8 billion (the independent evaluation of Job Keeper, 2022). Those amounts landed in the profit figures of the years they were received, and they are not maintainable.
The test is documentary. A buyer's adviser asks for the grant correspondence, the bank statements and the general ledger line, then asks what replaced that income the following year. If the answer is nothing, the adjustment stands and the earnings base falls.
A hypothetical illustration, clearly labelled as such. Take a sub-$2 million business that reported EBITDA of $400,000 in a base year in which it received $60,000 of COVID-era support that has not recurred. Notional arithmetic shows the sequence a buyer follows. Remove the non-recurring $60,000, and maintainable EBITDA falls to $340,000 for a forward-looking measure. At a 3.0x PEBITDA multiple, that one documentary point moves indicative enterprise value from $1.2 million to $1.02 million; a $180,000 difference on a single line, before any discussion of owner pay or working capital. The figures here are illustrative only, and real trading performance, growth prospects and buyer profile would all change the outcome.
Related-party terms
Related-party arrangements are where a sub-$2 million business most often carries hidden value or hidden cost. Rent paid to a family trust below market, a director's loan on non-commercial terms, or a management fee paid to an associated entity all distort the earnings figure, and all of them are visible to a buyer who reads the financial statements properly. Each is a debt-like item in the sense that a buyer treats it as an obligation to be restated or settled before the price is agreed.
The ATO's areas of focus for 2025–26 include trusts, Division 7A and succession planning, and the ATO states it continues to focus on tax risks arising from the increase in succession planning activities as private groups restructure, dispose of assets or transfer wealth (the ATO's areas of focus for 2025–26, last updated 16 Oct 2025). Related-party transfers are also among the situations where a market valuation may be required, alongside CGT events, small business CGT concessions, business restructures, shareholder buyouts, Division 7A transactions and transfers of business assets between entities (when accountants need an independent business valuer). Terms that shift profit to a related entity attract attention on both the tax and the valuation side, and a buyer will restate them to arm's length rates before settling on normalised earnings for the SME.
From EV to equity
Enterprise value is the value of the operating business. Equity value is what the owner actually receives, and the difference is the price bridge. A buyer who agrees to an enterprise value and then deducts net debt while adding surplus cash arrives at an indicative equity value (the firm's worked example on the EBITDA-to-PEBITDA bridge, 2026). The arithmetic is simple; the arguments about each line are not.
CFDF price bridge
The bridge runs in a fixed sequence: start with enterprise value, deduct net debt, add surplus cash, and the result is indicative equity value. Cash flow derived from the business, or CFDF, is the earnings measure that feeds the enterprise value at the top of the bridge, and every normalisation discussed above lands there. The bridge is where a valuation argument becomes a price argument, because a $100,000 disagreement about maintainable earnings becomes a $250,000 to $350,000 disagreement about enterprise value once a 2.5x to 3.5x PEBITDA multiple is applied.
The multiple itself is not a fixed number. SME multiples typically range from 0.8x to over 8.0x earnings, and larger professionally managed entities valued on EBITDA generally attract a multiple 0.5x to 0.7x higher than owner-operated businesses valued on PEBITDA, reflecting reduced owner dependency and lower perceived risk (Australian industry multiple benchmarks, 2026). That differential is the arithmetic behind the warning about add-backs and multiples.
Working capital peg
The working capital peg is the agreed level of working capital the business will hold at completion, and it is usually expressed as a dollar figure with a true-up mechanism. A buyer who acquires a business with $200,000 of working capital and finds $140,000 on completion will adjust the price by the difference, and the adjustment is mechanical rather than negotiable.
This is why working capital requirements not being understood appears on the exit readiness list alongside unsubstantiated EBITDA adjustments (the exit readiness checklist, 2026). The peg has to be set from a normalised average, not from the balance on the day the owner decided to sell, and it has to account for seasonality if the business has any.
Debt-like definitions
Debt-like items are obligations that a buyer treats as debt even though they may not appear as borrowings on the balance sheet, and the definition is negotiated in the sale and purchase agreement. Unpaid superannuation, accrued but untaken leave, deferred tax liabilities, and tax debts are the usual candidates. The ATO's own data shows how material that last category can be: small business collectable tax debt was $35.9 billion in 2024–25, up 118% from $16.5 billion in 2018–19 (the Auditor-General's report on small business tax debt, 30 June 2026).
The practical lesson is that the definition matters more than the label. A debt-like item that is not defined in the agreement is a debt-like item the buyer can argue for later, and every dollar of it comes off the equity value at the bottom of the bridge.
| Build the seller’s case before the buyer anchors the deal
Expert Business Advisors helps owners prepare the financial case, valuation position and transaction materials required for a competitive mid-market sale process. |
Final Take
The tax return is not the enemy. It is simply answering a different question from the one a buyer is asking, and the gap between the two is what a future maintainable earnings valuation exists to close. For a sub-$2 million Australian business, that gap is decided by three things: whether the earnings measure matches the buyer and the multiple, whether every normalisation is substantiated to the standard APES 225 paragraph 4.6 requires, and whether the enterprise value to equity value bridge is agreed before the offer is accepted rather than after.
The evidence base for getting this right is already in the owner's hands. Three years of financial statements, tax returns, management accounts, BAS statements and general ledger exports; the operational material covering customer concentration, supplier and lease agreements and the asset register; and the legal and transaction documents including shareholder agreements, trust deeds and loan agreements. Assembled before a buyer asks, that pack answers the diligence questions that otherwise become price reductions, earn-outs, indemnities or escrow.
The next step is not to commission a valuation. It is to build the bridge yourself, on one page, using your own numbers: enterprise value at the top, net debt deducted, surplus cash added, equity value at the bottom. Where you cannot substantiate a line, you have found the argument a buyer will make, and you have time to fix it before it costs you the deal.
Editorial note and disclaimer: This article provides general information about Australian business sales and valuation considerations. It is not a valuation opinion, legal advice, tax advice or financial advice. Outcomes depend on the business, buyer, market and negotiated transaction terms.
Selected references
- When accountants need an independent business valuer
- The 12% superannuation guarantee rate
- Australian industry multiple benchmarks



